Should Your Agency Do Spec? No! Yes. No Way. OK, Have to. Nope, Never. And, On And On.
Damn, that’s an age old and very perplexing question. I answered it in a chapter in my pitch book, The Levitan Pitch. Buy This Book. Win More Pitches. and have an excerpt on this subject below.
I have been thinking (rethinking) about the question of whether or not advertising agencies should do spec creative or not. It was sparked by David Gianastasio’s ADWEEK article, “Can Agencies Win If They Don’t Play the Spec Pitch Game? The pros and cons of creating free work to win work.” David cites the El Segundo agency High Wide & Handsome’s refusal to do spec work. As High Wide & Handsome says…
When Mike Wolfsohn and his two partners left Southern California agency Ignited in 2010 to form High Wide & Handsome, they vowed not to participate in competitive pitches requiring contenders to foot the bill for speculative creative work. Such exercises “demean the profession,” said Wolfsohn, who decries the process as “a reality show to impress some panel of judges. Pitches rarely resemble what a working relationship would be like between agency and client.”
OK, more power to them. And, they might be able to pull it off for four reasons: [Read more…] about Should Your Advertising Agency Do Spec Creative?